Arguments for the Welfare State from the Looney Left

“If a man is not a socialist in his youth, he has no heart. 

If he is not a conservative by the time he is 30, he has no head” 

Georges Clemenceau, Former French Prime Minister and one-time radical.


In my last column I made a case for a modern-day equivalent of the “poorhouse,” a place of last resort for my father’s generation.

From the comments on that column and elsewhere it appears we have a lot of immature citizens in this country who will never grow up and use their heads.

Clearly our practice of handing out free money, free food, free housing, free health care and a myriad of other goods and services to people with no accountability isn’t working.   It isn’t helping the poor and it is dragging our nation down into an economic abyss from which, if not corrected, there will be no escape.

Our government is serving as an enabler to those who prefer not to work, or at least not to work until such time that one can find the job of his or her dreams with a salary to go along with it.  

My poorhouse would be a safe place were individuals and families who are down or their luck and have no resources can go to be cared for until they can get back on their feet.  It, however, would not be a place where one is free to do as one pleases.  All able-bodied residents would be required to pull their own weight and share chores.  Free time would not be spent in front of the television.  It would be spent learning the skills necessary to gain and hold down a job.

Their paychecks and their savings accounts would be their ticket back to independent living.

Liberals hated this idea.

When they have no argument, they call you names, make unwarranted assumptions and question your character.

I was accused of wanting to abolish child labor laws and women’s suffrage.  One suggested that I was in favor of spreading disease among the poor in order to kill them off so I would not have to deal with them.  Another said that it was obvious from this column that I was not a Christian, equating a government handout with old-fashioned Christian charity.

Christian charity is an act of love which is undermined by our ever increasing welfare state.  Presently, we are spending a trillion dollars a year on welfare or four times the amount needed to lift every man, woman and child above the poverty level.  What’s wrong with this picture?

In addition to creating more welfare recipients, we have created an ever expanding group of “poverty pimps”  — those individuals inside and outside of government who make a cushy living by putting and keeping more and more people on the public dole.  This has to stop!

No more grants to quasi-charities that make money signing up welfare recipients!  Also, state and federal workers should be rewarded with bonuses for ever person they help make the transition from welfare to work, not the other way aroundOne of the big flaws in the 1996 Welfare Reform Act, which was otherwise a success, was something called “maintenance of effort.”  That simply means  that we have to keep spending what we are spending on welfare, — adjusted upward each year for inflation — even if there is only one person in the whole country left on the rolls.  This is nuts!

Let states keep the savings that come from transitioning people from welfare to work.  We hear so much about our crumbling infrastructure.  Let states spend this money on roads and bridges or, better still, give it back to the taxpayers.

What would happen to all those welfare workers who worked themselves right out of their jobs?  Reward them with golden parachutes so that they can start their own small businesses.

Another tactic of the left is to skew the facts or pick out just one fact that, by itself, would seem to make the case that our welfare system works.

Here’s the left’s favorite example: “The average time on welfare is less than two years.”  This is true.  However, what these welfare activists won’t tell you is that 65 percent of  people on welfare have been on those rolls for eight years or longer.

We are creating a permanent underclass and its growing each and every day.   This not only robs the taxpayers, it robs those on the receiving end of these handouts of their self respect and undermines their confidence and ambition.

What a waste!  We should be hanging our heads in shame.


2 thoughts on “Arguments for the Welfare State from the Looney Left

  1. Assuming that the leftists in the government who release the statistics are even telling the truth, there is a good reason why the average welfare recipient might appear to be on the rolls for only two years. When I worked for Sacramento County Welfare, the recipients were required to fill out a monthly reporting form and return it to us in a franked envelope…the “work” of perhaps three minutes per month.
    This was simply too much effort for many of these fifth generation queens, and they would set the form aside somewhere and forget about it; often it would be lost by them or by their pack of illegitimate children, each with a different father, most of whom were in prison. We were then required to suspend their benefits, and, when their check failed to arrive, they would come to our office, howling with rage, whereupon, at considerable extra expense, we would restart their benefits and issue them a special check. So some of them would be on, off, and back on welfare every few months…every few months for five generations and counting.


  2. Jane’s statement, “Our government is serving as an enabler” correctly identifies the problem. Getting government out of all areas of our lives is the answer, over-simplified but true. I’m afraid we are beyond a reversal of this trend of government dominance, government intrusion into our lives, and “jack-boot” law enforcement. It is depressing. The haunting lyrics of Buffalo Springfield’s 1966-67 song revisit me frequently:
    “There’s something happinin’ here,
    What it is ain’t exactly clear,
    There’s a man with a gun over there,
    A’tellin’ me I got to beware.
    S’time we stop, children,
    What’s that sound… Everybody look what’s goin’ down!
    HIstory repeating itself…and so soon!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s